KeptGovernment ReformPROMISE #1
Oust Speaker McCarthy via motion to vacate.
Verified
Verdict reasoning
Gaetz filed the October 2023 motion to vacate that succeeded 216-210 — the first time a sitting Speaker was removed by motion to vacate.
Back to all politicians
House · FL
Matthew Louis Gaetz II
R · FLAge 43· Conservative RepublicanStandard review
Matt Gaetz represented Florida's 1st congressional district from January 2017 to November 2024. He resigned after Trump nominated him for Attorney General; he withdrew the nomination amid resistance and did not return to Congress.
SEALED — The 2016 Promises — the original deep dive on Trump's 145 campaign promises
Read the original case study — $15CAMPAIGN RECEIPTS · 2022–2024 TERM
Matthew Louis Gaetz II
Republican·FL·House
64%kept · 14 promises graded
9kept
4partial
1broken
0You decide
campaignreceipts.com/politician/matt-gaetzVerified
Standard review — Primary sources, single editorial pass. Upgrade to full review when readers request it →
Ranking
- among Republican representatives5th of 113
- among all representatives5th of 260
Four promises that define the record
Promises that define the record.
Four promises chosen to span how voters across the political spectrum view this politician's record.
Every other promise on file
All tracked promises
#2
KeptTaxes
Cut taxes / extend TCJA.
Voted YES on the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (December 2017). Has consistently supported TCJA-extension framework.
#3
KeptJudiciary
Confirm conservative judges.
Voted YES on Justices Gorsuch (2017), Kavanaugh (2018), and Barrett (2020). Dobbs (2022) overturned Roe with all three in the majority.
#4
PartialHealthcare
Repeal Obamacare.
Voted YES on the 2017 'skinny repeal' (failed 49-51, McCain thumbs-down). Per /methodology, when the politician voted yes but the bill failed by a single dissenting vote from their own party, that's PARTIAL rather than BROKEN.
#5
KeptReproductive Rights
Pro-life / restrict abortion.
Voted NO on the Women's Health Protection Act. Supported confirmation of pro-life justices who overturned Roe.
#6
KeptGun Policy
Defend Second Amendment.
Voted NO on most federal gun-control measures during tenure. NRA rating A or A+.
#7
PartialImmigration
Aggressive border enforcement.
Voted YES on H.R. 2 framework. Position on the February 2024 Bipartisan Border Bill varied; comprehensive enforcement legislation did not pass during the Biden administration.
#8
KeptEnergy
Energy independence / oppose fossil-fuel restrictions.
Voted to expedite energy permitting and against Biden-era leasing restrictions. U.S. became net energy exporter (2019).
#9
BrokenFiscal
Hold the line on federal spending.
Voted YES on TCJA (CBO-projected $1.9T deficit) and CARES Act ($2.2T). National debt rose substantially during tenure.
#10
KeptReligious Liberty
Defend religious liberty.
Voted NO on the Respect for Marriage Act (citing religious-liberty concerns) and supported religious-liberty appropriations provisions.
#11
KeptForeign Policy
Support Israel.
Voted YES on Israel aid packages. Co-sponsored multiple Israel-support measures.
#12
KeptExecutive
Confirm Trump cabinet nominees.
Voted yes on Trump nominees including AG, SecDef, DNI, Treasury during the 119th Congress.
#13
PartialJudiciary
Block Biden judicial nominees.
Voted no on most Biden judicial nominees in minority. Could not block confirmation of Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson (April 2022, 53-47).
#14
PartialImmigration
Withdraw federal support for sanctuary cities.
Multiple bills introduced restricting federal funds to sanctuary jurisdictions; none reached final passage during the term.
Cast Your Vote
Want the deep-dive book on II?
With enough demand for objective journalism, SEALED Press researches and writes the next book in the series — full case studies, paper trails, and color-coded verdicts on every promise this politician has made.